? Explanation of report features  
Download hands in PBN or PDF format (Right click and choose “Save Link As...” in Firefox or “Save Target As...” in IE)
Jump directly to board 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
★ ★ ★  Masterpoint Winners  ★ ★ ★
Partnership Pct Rank MP
Andrew Calciano - Marilyn Calciano 60.48 1st A 0.40
John Wesolowski - Judy Osborn 58.29 2nd A 0.28
Laura McCabe - Leslie Davidson 55.48 1st A 0.40
Diane Gunter - Michael Modest 49.85 2nd A 0.28
EVENT>Monday Evening 199er Pair|SESSION>Monday Eve   |SECTION> A N-S
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>September 30, 2019 |CLUB NO.>267617    | 09/30/2019 21:15
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> Jan Winham      |RATING>Club Masterpoint (80%, 60%, 60% Open)|MOVEMENT>MITCHELL
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   40.0 |TOP>   4 |MP LIMITS>None/100/50    |CLUB>Bridge4Fun
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=5/B=3/C=2                       ,---,-------------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |           Section       |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 
 1 Susan Pearce           Richard Pearce           C    .     .     .     36.63  45.79          
 2 John Wesolowski        Judy Osborn              A    2     .     .     46.63  58.29  0.28(A) 
 3 Sharol Sevilla         Joy Gift                 B    .     .     .     29.38  36.73          
 4 Nancy Ficarrotta       John Walker              A    .     .     .     38.95  48.69          
 5 Marilyn Calciano       Andrew Calciano          C    1     1     .     48.38  60.48  0.40(A) 
                                          Totals                         199.97       

EVENT>Monday Evening 199er Pair|SESSION>Monday Eve   |SECTION> A E-W
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
AVE>   40.0 |TOP>   4 |MP LIMITS>None/100/50    |CLUB>Bridge4Fun
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=5/B=3/C=2                       ,---,-------------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |           Section       |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ --------- 
 1 Carol Cowen            Katherine Beiers         C    .     .     .     30.63  38.29          
 2 Lou Browning           Kenneth Girouard         C    .     .     .     36.13  45.16          
 3 Laura McCabe           Leslie Davidson          B    1     1     .     44.38  55.48  0.40(A) 
 4 David Harken           Jan Winham               A    NE    .     .     49.47  61.84          
 5 Michael Modest         Diane Gunter             A    2     .     .     39.88  49.85  0.28(A) 
                                          Totals                         200.49       

1 ♠9873
AK7
KQ86
♣62
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠Q42
QJT4
AJ53
♣87
♠AKJT
9852
-
♣AQJ53
♠65
63
T9742
♣KT94
12
1015
3
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2  ♣4 ♥3 ♠4 NT4
EW: 2/3♣ 4 2♠ 1/2NT  ♦5
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: -420 4-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          3.50   0.50  4♣ E -2   T  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 2-Browning-Girouard
  100          3.50   0.50  3♣ E -2   ♠6  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
        170    1.50   2.50  3 W +1   ♣6  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        170    1.50   2.50  2 E +2   T  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
        420    0.00   4.00  4 W      K  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 4-Harken-Winham
2 ♠KJ93
T96
K832
♣KQ
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠65
A87
AQJ6
♣T972
♠A82
KQJ5432
-
♣J43
♠QT74
-
T9754
♣A865
12
1111
6
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3 3♠  ♣6 ♥3/2 NT4/3
EW: 1♣ 4 3NT  ♦4 ♠4
LoTT: 19 - 19 = 0
Par: -200 4♠*-NS/4*-NS-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          3.50   0.50  4 E -1   T  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 2-Browning-Girouard
   50          3.50   0.50  4 E -1   ♣A  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
        420    1.00   3.00  4 E      ♠4  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
        420    1.00   3.00  4 E      ♠4  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        420    1.00   3.00  4 E      T  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 4-Harken-Winham
3 ♠Q5
QJT65
AQ76
♣AK
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠T7
-
KT95432
♣Q985
♠K9642
K9
J8
♣T732
♠AJ83
A87432
-
♣J64
18
57
10
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♣ 1 7 4♠ 6NT
EW:  ♣4 ♦6 ♥0 ♠3 NT1
LoTT: 19 - 20 = -1
Par: +1510 7-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
 1010          3.50   0.50  6 S +1   ♠T  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 2-Browning-Girouard
 1010          3.50   0.50  6 S +1   T  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
  980          1.50   2.50  6 S      T  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 5-Modest-Gunter
  980          1.50   2.50  6 S      3  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 4-Harken-Winham
  510          0.00   4.00  4 N +3   ♠4  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
4 ♠KJ9632
QT
AJT2
♣5
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠75
9732
K853
♣J94
♠T84
J64
Q6
♣QT632
♠AQ
AK85
974
♣AK87
11
45
20
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♣ 6 5 6♠ 6NT
EW:  ♣4 ♦1 ♥1 ♠1 NT1
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +1440 6NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
 1460          4.00   0.00  6♠ N +1   4  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
 1430          3.00   1.00  6♠ N      ♠4  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 4-Harken-Winham
  720          2.00   2.00  5N N +2   ♣2  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 5-Modest-Gunter
  680          1.00   3.00  5♠ N +1   Q  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
        100    0.00   4.00  6♠ N -1   4  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 2-Browning-Girouard
5 ♠AKQJ42
A9
AK9
♣A6
Dlr: North
Vul: N-S
♠9863
T875
J
♣KT75
♠7
K3
87432
♣Q8432
♠T5
QJ642
QT65
♣J9
25
45
6
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 4/5 5 6♠ 6NT  ♣5
EW: 1♣  ♦2 ♥1 ♠1 NT1
LoTT: 19 - 17 = +2
Par: +1400 7♣*-EW-6
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
 1430          4.00   0.00  6♠ N      3  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 2-Browning-Girouard
  690          3.00   1.00  3N N +3   ♣3  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
  660          2.00   2.00  3N N +2   ♣3  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 4-Harken-Winham
  650          1.00   3.00  4♠ N +1   ♠7  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
  230          0.00   4.00  2♠ N +4   ♣3  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 5-Modest-Gunter
6 ♠A52
QT96542
Q76
♣-
Dlr: East
Vul: E-W
♠974
AK8
AT93
♣974
♠KQT6
J7
854
♣AK32
♠J83
3
KJ2
♣QJT865
8
1113
8
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1/-♣ 2
       ♣7/6 ♦4 ♠5/4 NT5
EW: 2 1/2♠ 2NT  ♣6 ♥5
LoTT: 16 - 15 = +1
Par: -100 3*-NS-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
         50    4.00   0.00  3 N -1   ♣A  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
        120    3.00   1.00  2N W      6  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        500    2.00   2.00  4* N -3  4  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 2-Browning-Girouard
        600    0.50   3.50  3N W      T  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
        600    0.50   3.50  3N W      6  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 4-Harken-Winham
7 ♠A984
J5432
J65
♣2
Dlr: South
Vul: Both
♠JT653
KQ98
A2
♣A4
♠KQ7
6
KQ8743
♣853
♠2
AT7
T9
♣KQJT976
6
1410
10
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣  ♦2 ♥5/6 ♠2 NT2
EW: 3 4♠ 1NT  ♣5 ♥6
LoTT: 18 - 16 = +2
Par: -620 4♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          4.00   0.00  4♠ W -1   ♣2  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 2-Browning-Girouard
        140    3.00   1.00  3♠ W      ♣2  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
        200    1.50   2.50  3♠ W +2   ♣2  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 4-Harken-Winham
        200    1.50   2.50  5♣ S -2   A  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
        620    0.00   4.00  4♠ W      ♣2  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 5-Modest-Gunter
8 ♠A
KJ6
KJT2
♣A7642
Dlr: West
Vul: None
♠KT754
A
8643
♣KJ8
♠Q9862
Q73
Q5
♣953
♠J3
T98542
A97
♣QT
16
116
7
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♣ 3 4/5 1NT  ♠4
EW: 2♠  ♣4 ♦4 ♥2 NT6
LoTT: 19 - 19 = 0
Par: +450 5-S
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  450          4.00   0.00  4 S +1   ♠K  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
  420          3.00   1.00  4 S      ♠5  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 2-Browning-Girouard
  170          2.00   2.00  3 S +1   ♠5  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 5-Modest-Gunter
  100          0.50   3.50  4♠ W -2   J  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
  100          0.50   3.50  4♠ W -2   ♣A  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 4-Harken-Winham
9 ♠J98
T42
AJ953
♣AT
Dlr: North
Vul: E-W
♠763
AK53
K6
♣QJ52
♠KT54
Q8
87
♣K9843
♠AQ2
J976
QT42
♣76
10
138
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3 2 3NT  ♣5 ♠6
EW: 1♣  ♦4 ♥5 ♠5 NT4
LoTT: 16 - 18 = -2
Par: +400 3NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  130          4.00   0.00  3 N +1   ♣4  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 2-Browning-Girouard
  110          3.00   1.00  3 N      ♠4  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 4-Harken-Winham
         50    1.00   3.00  3 N -1   ♠4  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
         50    1.00   3.00  3 N -1   Q  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
         50    1.00   3.00  3 N -1   ♣4  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 5-Modest-Gunter
10 ♠AK84
KJT75
J6
♣T3
Dlr: East
Vul: Both
♠Q965
Q32
92
♣AQ74
♠JT7
A4
KT8543
♣K6
♠32
986
AQ7
♣J9852
12
1011
7
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣ 3 2NT  ♦6 ♠6
EW: 1  ♣5 ♥4 ♠6 NT5
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +140 3-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  200          3.50   0.50  2♠ W -2   ♣T  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 2-Browning-Girouard
  200          3.50   0.50  3 E -2   6  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
  110          1.50   2.50  2 N      ♠J  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
  110          1.50   2.50  2 N      5  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        100    0.00   4.00  3 N -1   ♠7  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 4-Harken-Winham
11 ♠K
5
AJ852
♣AKQJT8
Dlr: South
Vul: None
♠AQT5
K8
T943
♣764
♠987643
AT63
K
♣32
♠J2
QJ9742
Q76
♣95
18
97
6
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 4♣ 4 2  ♠3 NT5
EW: 3♠  ♣3 ♦3 ♥5 NT4
LoTT: 19 - 18 = +1
Par: +100 4♠*-EW-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  130          3.50   0.50  4♣ N      ♠9  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
  130          3.50   0.50  4♣ N      ♠7  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
         50    2.00   2.00  5♣ N -1   ♠6  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        140    1.00   3.00  2♠ W +1   ♣A  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 4-Harken-Winham
        150    0.00   4.00  4 S -3   ♠A  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 2-Browning-Girouard
12 ♠2
AQ2
AQJ8762
♣93
Dlr: West
Vul: N-S
♠T6
86
KT9
♣KT6542
♠KQJ873
J73
53
♣J7
♠A954
KT954
4
♣AQ8
13
68
13
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2/3♣ 5/6 7 1♠ 4NT
EW:  ♣4 ♦1 ♥0 ♠6 NT1
LoTT: 19 - 16 = +3
Par: +1700 7♠*-EW-7
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
 1430          4.00   0.00  6 S      ♠T  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 2-Browning-Girouard
  620          2.50   1.50  4 S      ♠T  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
  620          2.50   1.50  4 S      ♠T  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        100    0.50   3.50  4 S -1   ♠T  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 4-Harken-Winham
        100    0.50   3.50  4 S -1   ♠6  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
13 ♠K8643
T76
A4
♣QJ4
Dlr: North
Vul: Both
♠A752
J54
KQJT3
♣T
♠T9
Q
98752
♣A9853
♠QJ
AK9832
6
♣K762
10
116
13
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣ 4 2♠ 1NT  ♦3
EW: 4  ♣5 ♥3 ♠4 NT6
LoTT: 20 - 19 = +1
Par: +200 5*-EW-1
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  620          3.50   0.50  4 S      K  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
  620          3.50   0.50  4 S      ♣T  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
  170          1.50   2.50  3 S +1   K  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 4-Harken-Winham
  170          1.50   2.50  3 S +1   ♣T  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        100    0.00   4.00  4 S -1   ♣T  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 2-Browning-Girouard
14 ♠Q
Q42
AT965
♣AKQ7
Dlr: East
Vul: None
♠J765
6
K43
♣T8652
♠T42
AK875
87
♣J43
♠AK983
JT93
QJ2
♣9
17
48
11
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 3♣ 4 4 4♠ 5NT
EW:  ♣4 ♦1 ♥3 ♠2 NT2
LoTT: 14 - 16 = -2
Par: +460 5NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  490          4.00   0.00  3N S +3   6  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
  460          3.00   1.00  3N S +2   ♣5  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 5-Modest-Gunter
  430          2.00   2.00  3N N +1   7  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
  400          0.50   3.50  3N S      ♣5  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 2-Browning-Girouard
  400          0.50   3.50  3N N      3  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 4-Harken-Winham
15 ♠543
QJT84
KQ76
♣4
Dlr: South
Vul: N-S
♠KQ72
975
J54
♣Q32
♠6
A632
A83
♣AK875
♠AJT98
K
T92
♣JT96
8
815
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS: -/1 1♠  ♣5 ♦6/7 ♥6 NT6
EW: 2♣ 1NT  ♦6 ♥6 ♠5
LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: -90 1NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  100          4.00   0.00  3N W -2   Q  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
   50          3.00   1.00  3♣ E -1   K  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 4-Harken-Winham
        120    2.00   2.00  2N W      ♠5  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        130    1.00   3.00  3♣ E +1   K  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 2-Browning-Girouard
        200    0.00   4.00  3♠ S -2   ♣Q  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
16 ♠K9876
KT7542
-
♣97
Dlr: West
Vul: E-W
♠AJ43
J8
QT4
♣JT43
♠T5
963
KJ765
♣AQ2
♠Q2
AQ
A9832
♣K865
6
910
15
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♣ 4 3♠ 2NT  ♦5
EW: 1  ♣6 ♥3 ♠3 NT4
LoTT: 17 - 16 = +1
Par: +420 4-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  420          3.88   0.13  4 N      5  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
  170          2.63   1.38  3 N +1   ♠T  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 5-Modest-Gunter
  140          1.38   2.63  3 N      6  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 2-Browning-Girouard
        100    0.13   3.88  2 S -2   ♠A  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
17 ♠75
J7652
A5
♣J865
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠KQJ942
T94
93
♣AT
♠A3
Q
KQ862
♣KQ974
♠T86
AK83
JT74
♣32
6
1016
8
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1  ♣1 ♦3 ♠2 NT2
EW: 4♣ 3 5♠ 1NT  ♥6
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: -450 5♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
   50          4.00   0.00  3♣ E -1   A  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        420    2.50   1.50  4♠ W      ♠5  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
        420    2.50   1.50  4♠ W      5  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 4-Harken-Winham
        450    1.00   3.00  4♠ W +1   A  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
        480    0.00   4.00  4♠ W +2   A  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 2-Browning-Girouard
18 ♠K84
654
AQ8643
♣J
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠T732
932
9
♣K7532
♠Q6
AQJT8
J52
♣Q94
♠AJ95
K7
KT7
♣AT86
10
312
15
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1♣ 6 1 4♠ 5NT
EW:  ♣5 ♦1 ♥6/5 ♠2 NT2
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: +1370 6-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  650          4.00   0.00  4♠ S +1   9  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 5-Modest-Gunter
  210          3.00   1.00  1N S +4   ♣3  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 4-Harken-Winham
  170          1.50   2.50  4 N +2   A  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 2-Browning-Girouard
  170          1.50   2.50  3 S +3   A  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
  150          0.00   4.00  2 N +3   A  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
19 ♠95
J98763
K5
♣T53
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠J876
QT5
QJT8
♣92
♠QT3
K42
94
♣AQJ64
♠AK42
A
A7632
♣K87
4
612
18
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣ 2 3 1♠  NT6
EW: 1NT  ♣5 ♦4 ♥4 ♠6
LoTT: 15 - 14 = +1
Par: +140 3-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
  110          3.50   0.50  2♠ S      ♣9  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 5-Modest-Gunter
  110          3.50   0.50  2♠ S      ♣2  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
         50    1.50   2.50  3N S -1   ♣9  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 2-Browning-Girouard
         50    1.50   2.50  3N S -1   ♣9  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 3-McCabe-Davidson
        100    0.00   4.00  5 S -2   ♣9  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 4-Harken-Winham
20 ♠QJ97
3
K76
♣T9652
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠A3
AKT92
AQJ5
♣43
♠KT65
8764
T9
♣AJ8
♠842
QJ5
8432
♣KQ7
6
188
8
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣5 ♦2 ♥1 ♠4 NT2
EW: 2/1♣ 5/4 5 2♠ 5/4NT
LoTT: 16 - 17 = -1
Par: -660 5NT-W
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract  Ld
        200    4.00   0.00  3 W +2   ♠Q  2-Wesolowski-Osborn vs 4-Harken-Winham
        620    3.00   1.00  4 W      ♣T  1-Pearce-Pearce vs 2-Browning-Girouard
        650    1.50   2.50  4 W +1   ♠Q  5-Calciano-Calciano vs 5-Modest-Gunter
        650    1.50   2.50  4 W +1   6  3-Sevilla-Gift vs 1-Cowen-Beiers
        680    0.00   4.00  4 W +2   ♠Q  4-Ficarrotta-Walker vs 3-McCabe-Davidson